Source Control: Evil, a waste of time, too much work or something much better?

A great chalk talk (CT103 – Useful Tools for Getting the Most Out of NAV) with Waldo at Directions in Phoenix was my inspiration for this. I ended up high jacking part of Waldo’s session (so sorry Eric. I will try to restrain myself next time), because I could see so many possibilities for our community. After the session I had a great hall chat with Eric (Waldo) Wauters, Mark Brummel and Gary Winter (all 3 of them behind the Partner Ready Software initiative), sharing some of the things I have learned over the years of using source control.

The inspiration for this blog post came from this discussion.

So what is source code control and what benefits among others does it bring us:
· Source Code Control
· Product Management
· Code Review
· Branching strategies and Code Management

Let me go through each one and talk about the benefits.

Source Code Control is the obvious one. This is what everybody is thinking about when they think Source Code Control. We know what code was change, who did the change and when it was done. If this is all you are considering Source Code Control to be you need to keep reading. While it is all nice things they really don’t bring much value to the table. We are missing the most important information. Why was it changed? The “why” is the “Work Item” that caused this development to be done. The “Work Item” can be a Bug, a Task, an Issue, and so on. You properly have some kind of naming in your organization. If your Source Code Control system doesn’t track the reasons why we are making the changes it is only half implemented.

That brings me to Produce Management. Source Code Control is about securing your intellectual property, but if you only secure the code and not the understanding and reasoning of the code all you have is code and not intellectual property. Product management is about securing that you are doing the right things for your product for the right reasons.

Code Review. Sounds borrowing and might sound like you want to hit your developers with all the mistakes they make, but if that is what you are thinking of, you have the complete wrong approach. Code Review and Source Code Control makes it possible not only for the individual developer to review his/hers code before check-in, making sure that it is only the intended code that gets into the system. It also makes it possible for peer review causing the developers to learn tips and tricks from each other creating better and more error free code. This mentor process creates a better and stronger team with the highest class of developers.

Branching strategies: You might think I have gone completely off the deep end now and you will not be the first to think so, but in reality, this is one of the greatest benefits with source control that often is totally over looked. I did not hear anybody even mention it and this is an essential part of why everybody needs source code control. If you are creating releases or hotfixes the right setup is going to help you manage it all and with very little work. It is about being able to manage your code in a total transparent way.

So we have established that Source Code Control has more to offer then just “Source Code Control”. It should be part of every partners approach to development. I know we are all different and some of us develop verticals, others add-on’s and again others are doing purely horizontal project after project.

It doesn’t really matter who you are and what you do. If you are serious about NAV development, Source Code Control should be part of your planning.

Tags: , ,

2 Responses to “Source Control: Evil, a waste of time, too much work or something much better?”

  1. Gary Winter Says:

    Couldn’t agree more. The use of appropriate tools has been neglected in NAV environments for far too long with the object designer being the only development tool provided out of the box. - Code review and methodologies like Extreme Programming are indeed not meant to spy, but are essential cornerstones in writing good software, avoiding mistakes, and improving yourself. No professional approach to software can do without peer group code review mechanisms.

  2. Source Control: Evil, a waste of time, too much work or something much better? | Pardaan.com Says:

    […] Bron : Soren’s Blog Lees meer… […]

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security text shown in the picture. Click here to regenerate some new text.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word